Supervision
“Guidance should come from studies of
effective supervision, which have identified openness, availability, and clear feedback, including feedback about errors; on the other hand, ineffective supervision includes rigidity, low empathy, failure to offer support, and failure to follow the supervisees’ concerns.“
As of July 2023, the ACGME outlines distinct levels of supervision to ensure appropriate oversight and guidance for medical residents, fostering their learning and ensuring patient safety. These levels are:
Direct Supervision: This is the initial and most hands-on level of supervision. Under direct supervision, the supervising physician is physically present with the resident during crucial parts of patient interaction. Alternatively, in cases where the supervising physician and/or patient are not physically present, the supervising physician is actively monitoring the patient care through appropriate telecommunication technology. Notably, first-year residents (PGY-1) are required to begin with direct supervision to ensure they receive immediate guidance and support (Unless the ACGME RC chooses to permit this for PGY-1 residents….see specifics below)
KH Program
ACGEM Comments on Telecommunication Supervision
Anesthesiology
The use of telecommunication technology for direct supervision must not be used with invasive procedures, including the conduct of anesthesia; and…
the supervising physician and the resident must interact with each other, and the patient, to solicit the key elements of the clinic visit and agree
upon a management plan; and…
must be limited to history-taking and patient examination,
assessment, and counseling.
Emergency Medicine
The use of telecommunication is allowed for direct supervision.Â
Family Medicine
The use of telecommunication is allowed for direct supervision.Â
Psychiatry
 When a resident requiring direct supervision provides remote
care, the supervising physician must be physically present with the resident.Â
Psychiatry (Child and Adolescent)
The use of telecommunication is allowed for direct supervision.Â
Surgery
The use of telecommunication is NOT allowed for direct supervision.Â
Transistional Year
The use of telecommunication is NOT allowed for direct supervision.Â
2. Indirect Supervision: At this level, the supervising physician is not directly observing the resident; however, they remain immediately available for guidance. This means that while the supervising physician is not physically or concurrently observing the resident, they are readily accessible to provide direct supervision if needed. This level allows for a greater degree of autonomy for the resident while still ensuring support is available. Of note: Direct supervision must be immediately available.
3. Oversight: This is a more autonomous level of supervision where the supervising physician is available to review procedures and patient encounters, with feedback provided after the care is delivered. In this scenario, the supervising physician does not directly observe the resident but reviews their actions and decisions afterward. Programs must define specific situations where the physical presence of a supervising physician is mandatory.
Across these levels, the progression of a resident’s authority, independence, and supervisory roles in patient care is carefully managed. These privileges are granted by the program director and faculty members based on the resident’s experience, expertise, and demonstrated competence. This structured approach ensures that residents receive the appropriate level of supervision throughout their training, balancing the need for independent practice with the availability of guidance and support.Â